Case study – TRAVEL – GWR
Elevating a premium dining experience for GWR
Great Western Railway wanted to understand how its Pullman Dining Experience compared with other train operators and with fine dining venues, and how small changes to language and imagery could elevate the offer for different types of customer.
The challenge: A strong story that needed sharper positioning
Pullman Dining already carried a distinct sense of British nostalgia, but GWR wanted evidence of how that positioning compared with rival operators and with premium restaurants outside the rail sector. GWR needed a clear view of how competitors used language and imagery to sell a dining experience, and where Pullman sat within that wider landscape.
What we did: We compared rail dining with fine dining using LENS
Using our LENS approach, which combines semiotics and discourse analysis, we reviewed how rail operators presented their onboard dining, alongside premium restaurants in the wider category. Our discourse analyst and semiotician each reviewed every website in turn, then compared notes together to draw out the language and image patterns shaping how each brand was perceived.
What we found: A clear map of how dining brands earn their positioning
The analysis showed that every dining brand sits somewhere on a small set of scales, from functional to experiential and from historical to modern, and that small choices in wording and photography are what move a brand along them. This gave GWR a precise, evidenced framework for identifying exactly where Pullman's positioning could be sharpened, and how.
The impact: Practical direction, delivered fast
The research gave GWR specific direction on elevating the Pullman offer, from the language that signals culinary expertise to the imagery that reads as sociable rather than corporate, delivered within three weeks.
“With Magenta you get passion, you get challenge that affects thinking. Mix it all together and you realise you're working with a team that deliver brilliance, seemingly effortlessly.”
Head of Consumer Research, Great Western Railway
If you want to understand how your brand's language and imagery compare with the competition, let's talk.